Unnecessary Hip Surgeries on Children in Dublin: Can Parents Initiate a Claim? We were concerned to read the findings of the draft audit report into paediatric hip surgeries carried out in Ireland since 2021. The report reveals that a significant number of these procedures, 79% at Cappagh National Orthopaedic Hospital and 60% at Temple Street Children’s Hospital did not meet the clinical threshold for surgery, raising serious concerns about how and why these decisions were made. It’s an extremely concerning development, which has many implications for hundreds of families across the country. The surgeries were carried out on vulnerable children aged just one to seven, many of whom, it is now alleged, may have undergone invasive and unnecessary procedures. Hundreds of hip surgeries on children may have been carried out unnecessarily at Cappagh Hospital and Temple Street Children’s Hospital in Dublin The draft audit was prompted by a whistleblower’s claims that hundreds of hip surgeries on young children may have been carried out unnecessarily. For many families, this has reopened painful questions about their trust in the healthcare system. Donegal TD Pearse Doherty raised the issue in the Dáil, sharing stories from affected parents. One mother was notified that her four-year-old daughter’s surgery is now under review after already enduring serious health challenges following a premature birth. Another family, seeking a second opinion, were told their child didn’t need surgery at all and may not have even had the condition initially diagnosed. A Breach of Trust If confirmed, these findings could represent one of the most serious breaches of professional standards in Irish paediatric care. Unnecessary surgery on children carries not only physical and emotional consequences but also a lasting impact on trust in the medical profession. Even more troubling are allegations that some procedures may have been financially motivated. If true, this would be a clear violation of both ethical and legal responsibilities. For families now facing uncertainty, clear answers and accountability are urgently needed. Legal support is available to help guide them through the next steps. Surgical Negligence Claims: How Our Medical Negligence Solicitors in Dublin Can Help At Carvill Rickard LLP, we specialise in medical and professional negligence claims Dublin and across Ireland. We understand how overwhelming this situation is for affected families and we are here to provide clear, compassionate and effective legal support. If your child underwent hip surgery at either Cappagh or Temple Street since 2021, you may have legal grounds to pursue a claim. These claims are not just about compensation they are about accountability and ensuring no other family endures what yours has. We can help you: Obtain and review your child’s full medical records Secure an independent medical opinion Guide you through the complaints and legal processes Pursue justice through the courts, where appropriate Arrange an initial consultation with a Dublin-based solicitor with expertise in hip surgery negligence claims We’re here to help. Thanks to our in-depth understanding of the system and our ability to carefully screen cases, we’re confident in our ability to guide you through the process. Contact Us to arrange a consultation. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Each case is unique and should be assessed on its individual facts.  In contentious business, a solicitor may not calculate fees or other charges as a percentage or proportion of any award or settlement.